Citegeist

Citegeist

The paranormal podcast that puts the "ahh!" in bibliography

Citegeist is a paranormal history podcast exploring ghost stories and folklore through an archival lens. Each episode starts with a ghost story as it's typically told, then we dive into the archive for a ghoulish gossip sesh, digging through historic and archival records to uncover what really happened. You'll find that, oftentimes, the real history is stranger, and scarier, than ghosts.


Hosted by Joshua Spellman, archivist and librarian, who spends his days in the archive and his nights chasing down ghosts (in the historic record).

New episodes drop every two weeks. Subscribe now, and I'll see you in the stacks!

Gelston Castle and the Ghost of Aunt Harriet
CitegeistNovember 11, 2026x
8
00:33:1845.72 MB

Gelston Castle and the Ghost of Aunt Harriet

This episode explores the turbulent life of Harriet Douglas Kruger and her obsession with Gelston Castle in the Mohawk Valley, from a colossal granite sarcophagus burial to her fiery temper that allegedly haunts the ruins. It threads the castle’s shifting ownership with persistent paranormal

The Headless Horseman and Ghosts of Sleepy Hollow
CitegeistOctober 28, 2026x
7
00:36:2449.99 MB

The Headless Horseman and Ghosts of Sleepy Hollow

In this Halloween episode of Zeitgeist, host Joshua Spellman reads an abridged version of Washington Irving’s Legend of Sleepy Hollow and investigates the real workings behind the Headless Horseman. The show traces the tale’s roots in local folklore, the Hessian origin, and the real-life

Corpsewood Manor: Appalachia’s Gay Devil Worshippers
CitegeistOctober 21, 2026x
6
00:43:4960.17 MB

Corpsewood Manor: Appalachia’s Gay Devil Worshippers

A chilling tale of Corpsewood Manor in rural Georgia, this episode blends a haunted, ruins of castle filled with satanic art, secret labs, and a deadly night in 1982 with a critical look at how bias shapes stories. Host Joshua Spellman guides listeners through the rumors to find the truth.

The Ghostly Lovers of Mesilla's Double Eagle Restaurant
CitegeistOctober 14, 2026x
5
00:37:5852.14 MB

The Ghostly Lovers of Mesilla's Double Eagle Restaurant

In this episode, host Joshua Spellman revisits the Mesilla legend of the Double Eagle, a haunting rooted in a tragic forbidden romance between Armando and Inez and the family drama that followed. He blends a spooky retelling with archival digging, exploring the story’s historical

Murder Creek & the Halloween Murderess, Sadie McMullen
CitegeistOctober 07, 2026x
4
00:46:5864.5 MB

Murder Creek & the Halloween Murderess, Sadie McMullen

This episode explores the dark legends behind Murder Creek, weaving together the 19th century tale of Aweha and Gray Wolf whose deaths forged the creek’s name, with a chilling Halloween night tragedy seventy years later when Sadie McMullen lures and drowns two young girls on the Murder Creek